Warning over alcohol investments as fraud losses top £50m
Consumers are being warned about the dangers of unregulated alcohol investments, amid a surge in suspected fraud.
In the last four years, reports of fraud relating to investments in whisky and other alcohol products nationally have more than tripled, with total losses topping £50 million.
Now, the City of London Corporation’s Trading Standards team has published new guidance warning people to do their research about whisky cask and other alcohol investments and seek independent advice before parting with their cash.
Whisky and other alcohol investments have grown in popularity in recent years but unlike regulated investments, alcohol investments are not covered by financial compensation schemes if things go wrong.
City of London Corporation’s Port Health and Environmental Services Committee Peter Dunphy said:
“Alcohol investment fraud can have a devastating impact on people’s lives, with victims losing substantial sums of money and facing serious financial and emotional consequences.
“Consumers are often enticed by promises of significant returns which may never materialise, so it’s vital they take the time to understand the risks and seek independent advice before investing in unregulated products.”
The City Corporation is part of Operation Broadway, a multi-agency partnership aimed at disrupting investment fraud, with partners including financial regulators, HMRC and City of London Police.
Report Fraud, the UK’s national reporting service for cybercrime and fraud, received 112 reports nationally of alcohol investment fraud in 2023, rising to 174 the following year and 333 last year. With over 400 reports already this year, losses over the four-year period top £50 million.
People considering investing in alcohol are urged to do their research, seek independent advice and in particular ensure they will be the legal owner of the cask, not merely the person assigned to it.
They should insist on a full receipt, contract and details of storage or insurance costs and pay at least £101 by credit card, which will give them added legal protection.
The full guidance is available at https://tinyurl.com/bde2ubb8
Case study: ‘I got in over my head’
Mark*, a father-of-two, invested almost £200,000 in dozens of whisky casks after inheriting a considerable sum, seeking alternatives to leaving money in the bank. He was attracted by potential annual returns of up to 18% and saw the casks as a long-term nest egg for his children.
He became concerned when he tried to sell two casks and says he was ‘strung along’. A whistleblower at the company later told him one of his casks had been sold without his permission. After a lengthy process, he has secured most of the casks but a handful remain outstanding. He believes he paid well over their market value.
Mark said: “Whisky intrigued me because it matures over time and can become more valuable. I understood there were no guarantees, but I got carried away and, looking back, got in over my head.
“When I found out there were problems, I was gutted. Everything seemed legitimate, but I’ve spent a huge amount of my free time trying to get control of what I paid for. I feel naive and gullible.
“My advice is to do your research and get independent advice before handing over any money. Make sure you understand what you’re buying, what it’s actually worth and that the casks will be in your name.”
* name has been changed